josef chladek

on photobooks and books

Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2, MACK/MAPP, 2012, Broomberg


Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2

Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2, josefchladek.com


Sample page 1 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 1 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 2 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 2 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 3 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 3 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 4 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 4 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 5 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 5 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 6 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 6 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 7 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 7 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 8 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 8 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 9 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 9 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 10 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 10 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Sample page 11 for book "Broomberg, Adam  and Chanarin, Oliver  – Adam  Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin  - War Primer 2"

Sample page 11 for book "Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver – Adam Broomberg and Oliver Chanarin - War Primer 2", josefchladek.com

Other books by Broomberg, Adam and Chanarin, Oliver (see all)

Adam Broomberg & Oliver Chanarin - Holy Bible

Other books tagged Parr Badger Vol. 3 (see all)

Claudia Andujar & George Love - AmazôniaGian Butturini - LondonTrine Søndergaard - Now That You Are MineGian Butturini - LondonAlain Resnais and Jorge Semprun - RepéragesSalvador Costa - PunkJouko Lehtola - FinlandiaVarious - Blauwe maandag. Omdat mijn huis daar stond 24 maart 1975All Japan students photographers association - Kono chijo ni wareware no kuni ha nai 全日本学生写真連盟公害 - この地上にわれわれの国はないTenmei Kanoh - Fuck (加納 典明 – Fuck / 燃えるパーティー)

War Primer 2 is based on Bertholt Brecht's book "Kriegsfibel" from 1955, for the MACK book the edition from 1998 was used.

Ok, I confess, it was the first photobook ever I downloaded. Could not get my hands on one of the 100 copies MACK sold in 2011 - so that's the good part, you can easily download at no cost (http://mappeditions.com/publications/war-primer-2 ). I tried both, EPUB in Chrome and the version for iPad in the iBook-Reader. To be honest, both were very unsatisfying to use, not only for a book-lover but for a "user" as well. Flipping pages, scrolling, zooming (if possible), reading text is not the thing for me and a photobook.

But if you forget about that and concentrate on the photos (in the book - were they sticked completly to the page or could you look behind? - the electronic version won't let you know) even on the screen the "book" starts to work. Photos were mostly taken from the net (sometimes credited when known or just referenced by the URL) and placed over the original page. I had the advantage to have a copy of Brecht's book. So reading the text below the original page (in German, made it easier even more) looking at the pic Broomberg/Chanarin selected on screen - made a complex reading experience in the end. The remake for me is not only a modernized version, it sometimes is more cynical, more sad, more brutal and yes, I caught myself laughing too. Great and too bad the printrun was only 100 to make it an easier visual experience.

Below are a few pages/screenshots, I took the same pages that I show on 

http://www.josefchladek.com/book/bertolt_brecht_-_kriegsfibel

So you might try and compare (putting two browser-windows side by side)

 

Pages: 100+

Place: London

Year: 2012

Publisher: MACK/MAPP

Size: 33 × 24 cm (approx.)

Latest updates

Tehching Hsieh - One Year Performance 1978–1979Léon-Paul Fargue & Roger Parry & Fabian Loris - BanalitéRaymond Thompson Jr - It’s hard to stop rebels that time travelJacques Fivel - CHINON DCM-206Pedro J. Saavedra - Donde el viento da la vueltaAlbert Renger-Patzsch - Die Welt ist schön. Einhundert photographische Aufnahmen.Livio Piatti - zooreal - Menschen und TierePia Paulina Guilmoth & Jesse Bull Saffire - FishwormLudwig Kozma - Das Neue HausMichael Rathmayr - RemedyMikio Tobara - Document Miseinen (遠原 美喜男 - ドキュメント 未成年)Ray K. Metzker  - City Lux